Two people can look for the same product online and receive different prices, not because the cost of the goods has changed or because one of them has found an offer, but because an algorithm has analyzed the information available on each customer. Purchase history, internet searches and other personal data can be used to estimate how much a person is willing to spend. It is a practice known as surveillance pricing, which the New York City Council has decided to limit with a law approved on November 12.
The measure, which still awaits the signature of Mayor Zohran Mamdani, would prohibit some forms of customization of prices based on the collection and processing of consumer data. It does not therefore concern all situations where a product is sold at different prices, but those where the difference depends on the individual characteristics of the customer obtained through commercial surveillance systems.
To understand the distinction, just consider two situations. A supermarket can lower the price of a product for all customers using a loyalty card, or a site can offer a valid discount for anyone who makes a purchase during a promotion. Different is the case of a company that uses information collected about the behavior of a single person to determine what price to show them, without knowing how it was calculated. It is above all on this last mechanism which focuses the new legislation.
The possibility of applying personalized prices has grown with the diffusion of data collection systems and automated analysis tools. Companies can use information from visited sites, installed applications, geographic location or previous business transactions. These data, often combined with those purchased by companies specializing in consumer profiling, allow customers to split into categories and predict their behavior.
The system does not necessarily produce higher prices for everyone. It can also be used to offer targeted offers or purchase incentives. The problem identified by the advocates of the law is that the consumer does not always know what information was used to determine the price and does not have the tools to verify whether another person, at the same time, is paying less for the same product.
The issue had already been addressed by the Federal Trade Commission, the US federal authority dealing with consumer protection and competition. In January 2025 the agency had published preliminary results of a survey on companies providing customization tools for prices. The analysis had documented the use of detailed information on consumers, including location, online navigation and purchasing habits, to develop systems capable of modifying commercial offers based on the customer profile.
However, the FTC had distinguished the existence of these technologies from the demonstration that each company uses them effectively to charge more certain consumers: the availability of tools to customize prices does not mean that all online stores automatically apply different rates to their customers.
A New York debate also focused on the consequences that the ban might have for companies. On 17 November the State’s Business Council criticized both the national measure and a proposal for state law that intervenes on the same subject. According to the association, some formulations could also involve common business practices, such as loyalty programs and discounts reserved to certain categories of customers.
The president of the municipal council, Julie Menin, rejected this interpretation, claiming that the legislation distinguishes legitimate promotions from the prices established through individual profiling. The controversial point concerns above all the way this distinction will be applied: companies ask for rules sufficiently precise to avoid an authorized discount being considered a prohibited form of personalization.
This is not just about New York City. The state is also discussing the One Fair Price Act, a measure supported by Attorney General Letitia James to restrict the use of personal data in pricing. The two initiatives intervene on the same phenomenon, but have different legislative paths and application areas. The approval of the city law does not automatically involve the entry into force of that state.
Comparison with Europe helps to understand why the issue is complex. In the European Union there are already transparency obligations for traders who personalize prices on the basis of automated decisions. However, European legislation does not introduce a general ban on selling the same product at different prices. It is intended to inform the consumer when the price is customized through automated systems, leaving room for other rules on data protection and incorrect business practices.
In New York City the City Council has chosen a more restrictive approach to certain forms of use of personal data. Before the new rules can produce concrete effects, however, it is necessary to complete the legislative process and clarify how they will be applied.
L’articolo The same product can cost more according to who buys it: the City Council wants to ban it proviene da IlNewyorkese.